AO Smith vs Rheem Water Heaters: Which Is Better?

AO Smith water heaters are known for their energy efficiency and advanced technology, while Rheem water heaters offer a variety of models with reliable performance and innovative features; choosing between them depends on specific needs such as capacity, fuel type, and warranty options.

Choosing between AO Smith and Rheem water heaters can be tough. Both brands lead the market with reliable, efficient models. This guide compares their warranties, reliability, efficiency, and features to help you decide.

Side-by-side comparison of two water heaters in a home setting.

Brand Overview

Rheem Water Heaters

Rheem has been in the water heating industry since 1925. They offer a wide range of tank and tankless models. Rheem focuses on energy efficiency and smart technology. Many models feature Wi-Fi connectivity and self-cleaning systems.

AO Smith Water Heaters

AO Smith started in 1874 and is known for durable construction. They provide both traditional and tankless options. AO Smith emphasizes consistent performance and straightforward designs. Some models include basic smart features.

Visualize a side-by-side comparison of energy-efficient technologies in a vibrant infographic style.

Energy Efficiency Comparison

Energy efficiency is measured by the Uniform Energy Factor (UEF). Higher numbers mean better efficiency.

Model Brand UEF Rating
Performance Platinum 50-gal Rheem 0.82
Signature Premier 50-gal AO Smith 0.70

Rheem models typically have higher UEF ratings. This means lower energy bills over time. Their heat pump water heaters are especially efficient.

Warranty Coverage

Rheem Warranties

Rheem offers:

  • 6-12 year standard warranties
  • Up to 16 years with ProtectionPlus kits
  • Lifetime warranty on Marathon series

AO Smith Warranties

AO Smith provides:

  • 3-12 year limited warranties
  • 1 year labor coverage
  • Strict maintenance requirements

Rheem generally offers longer coverage periods. However, AO Smith warranties are still competitive for standard models.

READ MORE  How To Light A Whirlpool Water Heater?

Reliability and Lifespan

Both brands are reliable, but there are differences:

  • Rheem: 12-15 year average lifespan
  • AO Smith: 10-12 year average lifespan

Rheem’s aluminum anode rods help prevent corrosion. This extends tank life. AO Smith units may need more frequent anode rod replacements.

Installation and Maintenance

Installation

Rheem models often have simpler installation. Features like flexible venting help. AO Smith units may need more adjustments.

Maintenance

Both brands require:

  1. Annual tank flushing
  2. Anode rod inspections
  3. Temperature setting checks

Rheem’s self-cleaning models reduce sediment buildup. This means less maintenance over time.

Technology and Features

Rheem Features

  • EverKleen self-cleaning
  • EcoNet smart technology
  • High recovery rates

AO Smith Features

  • Durable glass-lined tanks
  • Basic Wi-Fi on select models
  • Simple controls

Rheem leads in smart features. AO Smith focuses on core performance. Consider your tech preferences when choosing.

Price Comparison

Prices vary by model and capacity:

  • Rheem: $600-$1,800
  • AO Smith: $500-$1,600

AO Smith models are often slightly cheaper upfront. However, Rheem’s efficiency may save more long-term. Check depreciation life when calculating costs.

Which Brand Should You Choose?

Choose Rheem if you want:

  • Higher energy efficiency
  • Longer warranties
  • Smart home integration

Choose AO Smith if you prefer:

  • Lower upfront cost
  • Simple, durable design
  • Basic functionality

Both brands make quality water heaters. Your decision should depend on specific needs and budget. For tankless options, see our tankless water heater guide.

Joye
Joye

I am a mechanical engineer and love doing research on different home and outdoor heating options. When I am not working, I love spending time with my family and friends. I also enjoy blogging about my findings and helping others to find the best heating options for their needs.