The best heating oil company in Long Island is often considered to be Petro Home Services, known for reliable delivery and excellent customer service.
Winter chills creeping in? Nothing’s worse than running out of heating oil during a Long Island freeze. High prices, unreliable deliveries, and hidden fees can turn a simple refill into a nightmare.
The right heating oil company can save you money, ensure timely deliveries, and keep your home cozy all season. In this guide, we’ll cover the top-rated providers, pricing strategies, and insider tips to maximize efficiency. For alternative heating solutions, explore our guide on hydronic boilers vs. heat pumps.
Key Takeaways
- Petro, Tragar, and Cashmere lead as top Long Island heating oil providers.
- Budget plans and automatic delivery services prevent mid-winter shortages.
- Compare per-gallon pricing, service fees, and customer reviews before committing.
- Consider switching to gas for long-term savings if oil costs rise.
Top 3 Heating Oil Companies on Long Island
1. Petro Home Services
With over 80 years in business, Petro dominates Long Island’s heating oil market. Their SmartPay budget plan spreads payments evenly, avoiding seasonal bill spikes. Customers praise their 24/7 emergency service—critical during Nor’easters. Expect transparent pricing with no hidden fees, though their per-gallon rates run slightly higher than smaller competitors.
2. Tragar Express
A family-owned business since 1957, Tragar offers same-day delivery for last-minute needs. Their Price Protection Program locks in rates before winter hikes. Unique perk: free annual furnace tune-ups with a service contract. Downsides? Limited coverage in western Suffolk County.
3. Cashmere Energy
Known for lowest-price guarantees, Cashmere suits budget-conscious homeowners. Their app tracks tank levels and schedules deliveries automatically. However, some users report longer wait times during peak demand. Ideal for those who plan ahead.
How to Choose the Best Provider
Pricing Structures Compared
| Company | Avg. Price/Gallon | Service Fee | Discounts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Petro | $4.19 | $25 | 10% prepay |
| Tragar | $3.89 | $15 | Referral credits |
| Cashmere | $3.75 | $0 | Autopay savings |
Service Areas & Reliability
Most providers cover Nassau County fully, but Suffolk’s eastern end has fewer options. Always verify coverage before signing up. For rural homes, consider propane hybrids—read our propane vs. electric heater comparison.
FAQs
How often should I refill my oil tank?
Monitor levels monthly. A 275-gallon tank lasts ~6-8 weeks in winter for an average 2,000 sq ft home.
Are budget plans worth it?
Yes, if you prefer predictable payments. Providers like Petro divide annual usage into 11 fixed installments.
What’s the cheapest delivery minimum?
100 gallons is standard, but some companies charge extra for deliveries under 150 gallons.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right heating oil company ensures warmth without financial stress. Compare rates, read reviews, and consider auto-delivery for hassle-free service. For more energy tips, explore our programmable thermostat guide.
