For most people replacing a gas fire, the R.W.FLAME 23-inch insert is the closest match here: it offers 750W and 1,500W heat, flame effects without heat, and recessed or freestanding use. Measure your opening first; the listed dimensions are 23.15 by 18.5 by 6.52 inches, and fit matters more than the flame colors.
The essentials
Measure the opening at its narrowest points, including width, height, and depth.
The 23-inch R.W.FLAME is the clearest insert choice in this product set; confirm the manual’s installation requirements before buying.
A 1,500W electric heater uses 1.5 kWh per hour at full power; multiply by your electricity rate to estimate cost.
A gas-to-electric conversion may require a professional to disconnect and cap the gas line.
Plug electric heaters directly into a wall outlet, keep 3 feet of clearance, and check the product’s safety listing.
Say your fireplace opening is 24 inches wide and 19 inches high. The 23.15-by-18.5-inch insert may fit across those dimensions, but you still need to check depth, clearance, and access to an outlet before ordering.
These picks are not all inserts: the list includes a wall-mounted unit and freestanding fireplace stoves. One listed product is a small space heater, not a fireplace insert, so it should not be presented as a substitute for one.
Five Electric Fireplace Picks, Ranked
#1Best Existing-Fireplace Fit
R.W.FLAME 23-Inch Fireplace Insert
Best for Existing fireplace openings that fit its listed dimensions
For replacing a gas fire with an electric option, this is the closest match in the group: it’s designed for recessed or freestanding use and offers 750W and 1,500W heat settings. You can run the flame effect without heat, with multiple flame, log-color, speed, and brightness settings.
Dimensions 23.15 W × 18.5 H × 6.52 D inchesHeat settings 750W and 1,500WInstallation Recessed or freestandingFlame controls 4 flame colors, 12 log colors, 5 flame speeds, adjustable brSafety listing ETL certified
Why it made the cut
Recessed or freestanding installation
Flame effect works with or without heat
Remote and touch-screen controls
Good to know
Opening must fit its 23.15-by-18.5-by-6.52-inch dimensions
No thermostat temperature range is stated in the product data
Skip it if Skip it if your opening is too small or you want a wall-mounted fireplace.
Best for A larger fireplace project needing recessed, wall-mounted, or freestanding setup
The 36-inch unit gives you three installation choices, including wall mounting when you don’t have an existing fireplace opening. Its 750W and 1,500W settings, remote, and separately adjustable flame and ember-bed lighting suit someone who wants more control over both placement and appearance.
Width 36 inchesHeat settings 750W and 1,500WInstallation Recessed, wall-mounted, or freestandingThermostat range 50°F to 95°FTimer 12 hours
Why it made the cut
Recessed, wall-mounted, or freestanding installation
750W and 1,500W heat settings
Separate flame and ember-bed lighting controls
Good to know
Its 36-inch width may not suit a small fireplace opening
The product data does not state a safety listing
Skip it if Skip it if you need a compact insert sized for a smaller existing opening.
Best for Rooms where you want a portable fireplace look and flame without heat
This is a freestanding heater, not a fireplace insert, but its flame effect can run without heat and its 750W and 1,500W settings provide two heat levels. The remote, touch panel, and 12-hour timer make it a practical choice when you want to move the unit between rooms.
Dimensions 23.6 × 6.7 × 17.3 inchesHeat settings 750W and 1,500WInstallation FreestandingThermostat range 59°F to 99°FTimer 12 hours
Why it made the cut
Flame effect works with or without heat
Remote and touch-panel controls
Overheat and tip-over protection
Good to know
Freestanding design won’t fit into an existing fireplace opening
The product data does not state a safety listing
Skip it if Skip it if you specifically need a recessed insert or wall-mounted fireplace.
Best for A freestanding stove-style heater with knob-and-switch controls
The ROVSUN is a freestanding stove, so it’s a better fit for adding fireplace-style warmth than replacing a gas insert inside an opening. Its 1,400W heat and temperature control from 68°F to 95°F suit a room where you want straightforward settings, while the flame effect adds a traditional look.
Height 23 inchesHeat setting 1,400WInstallation FreestandingThermostat range 68°F to 95°FSafety listing CSA listed
Why it made the cut
Temperature control from 68°F to 95°F
Overheat protection and tip-over switch
CSA listed
Good to know
Freestanding stove style, not an insert
The product data does not state a lower heat setting
Skip it if Skip it if you need an electric unit that fits inside an existing fireplace opening.
Best for Portable spot heating when fireplace appearance isn’t the priority
This is a conventional ceramic space heater rather than an electric fireplace, so it won’t fill an existing fireplace opening or provide a flame effect. It does offer 1,500W heat, a thermostat, a remote, and a timer for someone who mainly wants portable warmth in a small room.
Heat settings 1,500WInstallation PortableCoverage claim Up to 200 sq. ft.Timer 24 hoursSafety listing ETL certified
Why it made the cut
1,500W heat setting
Remote, thermostat, and 24-hour timer
ETL certified with tip-over and overheat protection
Good to know
No fireplace insert or flame effect
The product data does not state a fireplace-style installation option
Skip it if Skip it if you’re replacing a gas fire or want a visible electric flame.
Yes, you can transform a gas fireplace to electric by placing an electric insert in some former gas-fire openings, but the opening must fit and the gas appliance must be safely disconnected first. Can we get an electric insert for a gas fireplace? Often, yes—but setting an insert in place does not disconnect or make safe the gas line, burner or vent.
Have a qualified professional disconnect and cap the gas line before installation. Don’t cover an active connection or leave it hidden behind the insert; the new appliance doesn’t remove that hazard. Check the insert’s instructions for installation requirements, including whether it needs a nearby standard outlet and how it should sit in the opening. Don’t assume every model suits every gas fireplace.
Check the Side Clearance
Say the opening is 24 inches wide and the insert is 23.15 inches wide. The difference is 0.85 inch total, or about 0.43 inch per side if centered—before you check the manual for required clearance or account for an uneven opening.
Opening width24 in
Insert width23.15 in
Remaining width0.85 in total
Don’t Hide an Active Gas Line
A qualified professional should handle gas disconnection and capping. If the line is still active, don’t install the insert over it or try to make the connection safe by covering it.
An electric insert replaces the visible fire effect and can provide electric heat, but it doesn’t convert the gas fireplace’s plumbing or venting into electric equipment. Check the product instructions and the condition of the existing fireplace before choosing an installation approach. For more insert options, see electric inserts for fireplaces.
Measure the Fireplace Opening Before You Buy
To measure a fireplace for an electric insert, check the opening’s width, height and depth at their tightest points, then check the hearth and the route to a suitable outlet. Compare those measurements with the product’s outer dimensions—not a rounded size in its name—before you buy an electric insert for an existing fireplace.
1
Measure the narrowest width
Check across the opening at more than one height; note the smallest measurement, especially if the sides taper or angle inward.
2
Measure the lowest height
Measure from the hearth or floor to the top of the opening at the tightest point.
3
Check usable depth
Measure from the front edge to the back wall, watching for masonry or other obstructions.
4
Check the route to power
Confirm there’s a suitable outlet within reach and that the cord can be routed as the product instructions allow.
Use the Full Dimensions
The R.W.FLAME insert measures 23.15 by 18.5 by 6.52 inches. An opening that seems close to 23 inches wide may still be too narrow, too short or too shallow; those dimensions are a comparison point, not a guarantee of fit.
Product dimensions23.15 × 18.5 × 6.52 in
Check againstYour tightest opening measurements
Use the Manual for Clearances
There’s no universal air-space figure for every electric insert. Follow the manufacturer’s specified clearance and installation method for the exact model.
Installing an electric fireplace insert in an old wood fireplace avoids burning fuel in the insert, but the unit still needs the clearances and installation method stated in its manual. Inspect the opening and existing chimney condition; don’t assume the insert makes the chimney or fireplace sound. If the firebox won’t fit an insert, a freestanding electric stove or wall fireplace may suit the room, but it’s a different installation. See electric wall fireplaces for that alternative.
Compare Heat, Flame Controls, and Installation Style
The R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert is the direct insert choice; the other fireplace-style picks are different formats, and one is a portable space heater. Compare the details that are stated before treating any of them as a match for your existing opening.
Pick
What’s stated
What that means
R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert
23.15 × 18.5 × 6.52 in.; 750W and 1,500W; flame effect without heat; recessed or freestanding use
The only listed direct insert; measure the opening before buying.
DUMOS 36-inch Electric Fireplace
36 in.; recessed, wall-mounted or freestanding
A larger, flexible-format fireplace, not the 23-inch insert.
ROVSUN Electric Fireplace Stove
1,400W; freestanding
A stove-style heater, not an insert.
LifePlus 1,500W Electric Fireplace Heater
Freestanding; 1,500W
A freestanding heater, not an insert.
R.W.FLAME Small Space Heater
Portable ceramic space heater
Not an electric fireplace insert; leave it out of the insert rankings.
The supplied product details don’t establish timer, noise, flame-control, listing or safety-protection features for every pick. Check each model’s manual and label; one product’s certification or protection doesn’t apply to the others.
Myth
Every electric fireplace-style product is an insert and can heat a whole room as primary heat.
Fact
The product format matters: a freestanding stove or portable ceramic heater won’t fit an existing fireplace as an insert. A 750W or 1,500W setting tells you the electrical heat input, not how large a room the unit can heat or whether it can replace your main heating system.
The R.W.FLAME insert’s flame effect can run without heat, which suits you if you want the look in milder weather. Its 750W and 1,500W settings give you a lower and a higher output; neither setting alone proves the unit will keep a particular room warm. Check the manual for any timer, noise, flame-control, listing and protection claims before you choose.
Estimate Running Cost and Use the Heater Safely
At an assumed electricity rate of $0.17 per kWh, running a 1,500W setting for one hour costs about $0.26 before the heater cycles off. Your actual bill depends on your local rate and how long the heating element runs.
Heater
Watts
Per hour
Per day (1 h)
Per month (1 days)
1,500W setting
1,500 W
26¢
26¢
26¢
750W setting
750 W
13¢
13¢
13¢
Calculated at 17¢ per kWh. Assumes both settings run continuously for one hour at $0.17 per kWh. The 750W setting uses half the energy per hour of 1,500W when both run continuously.
Plug Into the Wall
Connect an electric heater directly to a wall outlet, never an extension cord or power strip. Keep at least 3 feet of clearance from combustibles. Don’t run it while you’re asleep or away unless the manufacturer says that model is designed for it; follow the manual, and keep children and pets away from hot surfaces and outlets.
Check the Exact Model
Look for a UL, ETL or CSA listing and, where applicable, tip-over and overheat protection on the specific unit’s label or in its manual. Don’t assume a feature or listing shown for one pick carries over to another.
Choose Your Next Step in the Right Order
Start with the fireplace you have, then confirm the insert fits before you order; the right sequence avoids buying a heater that can’t be installed safely.
1
If you have a gas fireplace
Arrange safe disconnection of the gas appliance first through a qualified professional. Then measure the opening and confirm you can reach a suitable outlet without an extension cord or power strip.
2
If you have an old wood fireplace
Measure the opening at its tightest points, then read the insert’s installation instructions for fit and required clearances before ordering. A firebox that looks roomy may still be too shallow.
3
If the opening won’t fit
Don’t force an insert into place or alter it to make it fit. Consider a freestanding stove, such as the ROVSUN 1400W Electric Fireplace Stove, or a wall-mounted fireplace instead; compare formats in this guide to recessed electric wall fireplaces.
Before You Buy
Identify whether the fireplace is gas or wood-burning.
Measure the opening at its narrowest points.
Verify the unit’s fit and required clearances in its instructions.
Confirm outlet access and the model’s safety details.
Buy only after those checks pass.
More Questions, Answered
Can you put an electric insert in a gas fireplace?
Yes, if the electric insert fits and the gas appliance is disconnected and made safe. Have a qualified gas professional handle the gas line and confirm the opening is suitable before installation.
How do you measure a fireplace opening for an electric insert?
Measure the width, height and depth at the narrowest points, since an opening can taper or have obstructions. Compare those measurements with the insert’s listed dimensions and allow for any clearance the manufacturer requires.
Can you install an electric fireplace insert in an old wood fireplace?
Often, provided the insert fits and the fireplace opening and hearth support the installation described in its manual. A capped or unused chimney does not automatically make every insert suitable; follow the manufacturer’s instructions and local requirements.
How much air space does an electric fireplace insert need?
There isn’t one clearance that applies to every insert; use the minimum clearances in that model’s manual. Keep the heater outlet unobstructed, and plug the unit directly into a wall outlet rather than an extension cord or power strip.