Transform Your Fireplace: 5 Electric Inserts You Didn’t Know You Needed

The best electric insert for existing fireplace installation is the GLACER 28.5” Electric Fireplace Insert. It offers adjustable flame colors and convenient remote control, making it perfect for modern homes.

Electric fireplace inserts are essential for enhancing your home’s ambiance and warmth. The GLACER 28.5” Electric Fireplace Insert stands out with its versatile design, allowing for both recessed and freestanding installation. With an adjustable flame color and a powerful heating option, it ensures comfort and style.

Discover how the PuraFlame Western 33″ and LegendFlame 25″ models offer unique features like realistic crackling sounds and remote control convenience. These inserts are ideal for transforming any space into a cozy retreat, providing both functionality and aesthetic appeal.

In this full review, you’ll learn about the best electric fireplace inserts available, including their features, benefits, and why they are a must-have for your home. Get ready to find the perfect solution for your fireplace needs!

best electric insert for existing fireplace installation

#1 CHOICE

The GLACER 28.5” Electric Fireplace Insert is designed to provide warmth and ambiance, making it ideal for homeowners looking to enhance their living spaces. This electric fireplace is particularly suited for those with existing fireplaces or those wanting a stylish heater that can be recessed or freestanding. With dimensions of 28.5” x 21” x 6”, it fits seamlessly into various settings, whether mounted in a wall or placed on a cabinet. The sleek black design adds a modern touch to any room.

One of the standout features of the GLACER Electric Fireplace Insert is its energy-saving capabilities. With two heat settings (750W and 1500W), it can efficiently heat rooms up to 400 square feet, ensuring comfort without excessive energy consumption. Users can also enjoy the flame effect without heat, making it a versatile decor element year-round.

Additionally, the realistic flame presentation, complete with glowing resin logs and ember beds, creates a cozy atmosphere. With three flame colors and five brightness levels, users can customize their experience to suit their mood. The included remote control makes it easy to adjust settings from a distance, enhancing user convenience.

Pros

• Energy-efficient design saves on electricity bills.
• Realistic flame effect enhances the ambiance of any room.
• Remote control allows for easy operation from up to 20 feet away.
• Multiple installation options provide flexibility in setup.
• ETL certified for safety, with overheating protection features.

Cons

• Limited to electric use, may not appeal to those preferring traditional fireplaces.
• The size may not fit all smaller spaces or designs.
• Price point may be higher compared to basic electric heaters.

Overall, the GLACER 28.5” Electric Fireplace Insert is best suited for homeowners seeking a stylish and functional heating solution. Its combination of realistic aesthetics and practical features makes it a valuable addition to any living space. While there are minor limitations regarding size and price, the benefits of energy efficiency, safety, and customizable ambiance make this electric fireplace insert a worthwhile investment for enhancing home comfort.

To buy this product, Check price on Amazon.

#2 CHOICE

The PuraFlame Western 33″ Electric Fireplace Insert is designed to bring warmth and ambiance to your living space, making it ideal for homeowners looking to enhance their existing fireplace. This electric insert is particularly suited for those who appreciate the aesthetics of a traditional fireplace without the maintenance hassles. With overall dimensions of 44.1″ wide, 31.5″ high, and 8.8″ deep, it fits seamlessly into standard fireplace openings, offering a modern touch to any room.

Constructed with a sleek black finish and featuring a three-sided interior brick wall design, the PuraFlame Western not only looks stunning but also provides a realistic fire experience. The life-like resin log, standing at 11 13/16″ high, sits beautifully above the ember bed, mimicking the appearance of a wood-burning fireplace. This electric fireplace insert utilizes 100% energy-saving LED technology, allowing you to enjoy the flame effects year-round, regardless of the heating function.

Performance-wise, the PuraFlame Western offers three flame settings with variable intensity and brightness, ensuring you can customize the ambiance to suit your mood. It features an adjustable thermostat and can heat spaces up to 400 sq. ft., making it a perfect supplemental heat source for chilly evenings. The included remote control adds convenience, allowing users to adjust settings from anywhere in the room.

Pros

• Realistic flame effects enhance ambiance without the mess of ashes.
• Durable construction with energy-efficient LED technology.
• Easy installation; simply plug in and use.
• Remote control for effortless operation.
• Adjustable thermostat for personalized heating control.

Cons

• Cannot be used as a primary heat source.
• Limited to a maximum heating area of 400 sq. ft.
• Requires a standard electrical outlet; cannot be hardwired.

Overall, the PuraFlame Western 33″ Electric Fireplace Insert is an excellent choice for those seeking a stylish and functional heating solution. Its blend of aesthetic appeal and practicality makes it best suited for homeowners who want to upgrade their existing fireplace without the commitment of a traditional wood-burning option. With its user-friendly features and realistic design, this electric insert is a valuable addition to any home.

To buy this product, Check price on Amazon.

#3 CHOICE

LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484) is designed to provide a cozy ambiance while offering supplemental heating, ideal for homeowners looking to enhance their living spaces. This electric fireplace insert is perfect for various settings, whether in a small apartment or a spacious living room. With dimensions of 25″ W x 20″ H x 10″ D, it fits seamlessly into existing openings or cabinets, making installation a breeze.

This product’s standout feature is its stunning flame effect, created using realistic resin logs and an ember bed, which looks even more appealing than traditional wood-burning fireplaces. The 100% energy-saving LED technology not only enhances the aesthetic but also helps reduce energy bills, allowing users to enjoy the beautiful flame effect all year round, with or without the heater. It effectively heats rooms up to 400 square feet without the hassle of dust, smoke, or compliance with local wood-burning regulations. However, it’s important to note that this device is not intended as a primary heat source.

Pros

• Stunning, realistic flame effect enhances home decor.
• Energy-efficient LED technology reduces electricity costs.
• Easy installation; simply place it into the opening.
• Remote control for convenient operation from anywhere in the room.
• CSA Certified, ensuring safety and reliability.

Cons

• Not suitable as a primary heat source.
• Requires a standard 120V outlet, which may limit placement options.
• Some users may find the price slightly higher than traditional options.

In real-world usability, the LegendFlame electric fireplace excels in providing both warmth and ambiance without the mess associated with wood-burning fireplaces. Its remote control feature adds convenience, making it easy to adjust settings without leaving your seat. While it may not replace a furnace, it serves as an excellent supplemental heater, especially in milder climates.

This electric fireplace is best suited for individuals or families looking to create a warm, inviting atmosphere in their homes without the drawbacks of traditional fireplaces. Its combination of aesthetic appeal and functional heating capabilities makes it a valuable addition to any living space.

To buy this product, Check price on Amazon.

#4 CHOICE

The Valuxhome Electric Fireplace is designed to provide both warmth and ambiance, making it an ideal choice for homeowners looking to enhance their living spaces. This 36-inch fireplace insert is perfect for those who appreciate the charm of a traditional fireplace without the hassle of wood or gas. Its dimensions of 35.63″W x 8.84″D x 27.5″H allow for easy installation in various settings, such as under a TV or within an entertainment center. The sleek black finish complements modern decor, while the energy-efficient design ensures a cozy atmosphere for rooms up to 400 sq. ft.

One of the standout features of the Valuxhome Electric Fireplace is its ability to provide supplemental heat quickly, with a heating capacity of 750/1500W and 5000 BTU. This means you can enjoy a warm and inviting environment in just a few minutes, making it perfect for chilly evenings. Additionally, the fireplace offers five flame brightness levels and three color options (yellow, blue, and purple) using LED technology, allowing users to customize the ambiance to suit their mood.

Pros

• Fast heating capability for rooms up to 400 sq. ft.
• Realistic flame effects and crackling sound for an authentic experience.
• Energy-efficient with no gas or oil required, ensuring a smokeless environment.
• Overheating protection for added safety during use.
• Versatile design that fits well in various home settings.

Cons

• Limited to electric use; no option for traditional wood burning.
• Requires a power outlet, which may limit placement options.

In real-world usability, the Valuxhome Electric Fireplace excels in providing a cozy atmosphere while being easy to operate with a remote control. The 6-foot power cable allows for flexible placement, but users should consider the proximity to an outlet. This electric fireplace is best suited for those who want the aesthetic appeal of a fireplace without the maintenance and clean-up associated with traditional models.

Overall, the Valuxhome Electric Fireplace is a valuable addition to any home, especially for individuals seeking a modern heating solution that enhances comfort and style. Its combination of safety features, aesthetic options, and efficient heating makes it an excellent choice for creating a warm and inviting space.

To buy this product, Check price on Amazon.

#5 CHOICE

The Sweetcrispy 60″ Electric Fireplace Wall Mounted or Recessed Insert serves as a stylish and functional heating solution, perfect for homeowners seeking to enhance their indoor ambiance. This electric fireplace is designed for a variety of users, including families, couples, and individuals who appreciate the cozy atmosphere of a fire without the hassle of traditional wood-burning options. With dimensions of 60 inches in length and a slim profile of just 3.9 inches, it seamlessly fits into any living room, bedroom, or even on a tabletop, making it a versatile addition to your home decor.

This electric fireplace boasts impressive specifications, featuring both 1500W and 750W heating modes that produce a powerful 5100 BTU output. Users can easily adjust the temperature from 59°F to 95°F, ensuring comfort during chilly nights. The fireplace also showcases an array of 169 color options, including 13 flame colors and 13 ember bed colors, allowing for endless customization to match your mood or decor.

Pros

• Powerful heating capabilities with adjustable temperature settings.
• Extensive color options for personalized ambiance.
• User-friendly remote control for easy adjustments.
• Three installation methods for versatile placement.
• Quiet operation under 40 decibels, ensuring a peaceful environment.

Cons

• Requires access to an electrical outlet for operation.
• Initial setup may require assistance for wall mounting or recessed installation.

The performance of the Sweetcrispy Electric Fireplace stands out due to its unique features, including a Sleep Mode for restful nights and a Recreation Mode for lively gatherings. Its three installation methods—recessed, wall-mounted, or freestanding—offer flexibility, making it suitable for various spaces. However, potential buyers should consider that it needs to be plugged into an electrical outlet, and wall installation may require professional help.

In summary, the Sweetcrispy 60″ Electric Fireplace is an excellent choice for those looking to combine style and functionality in their heating solution. Its customizable features and powerful heating capabilities make it ideal for families and individuals who value both comfort and aesthetics in their living spaces.

To buy this product, Check price on Amazon.

The shortlist

1

Best Overall InsertR.W.FLAME 30-Inch Recessed Fireplace

Existing fireplaces needing recessed or wall-mounted electric heat

Check price on Amazon

2

Best Freestanding StyleR.W.FLAME 17-Inch Electric Stove

Rooms that need a portable, vintage-style electric fireplace

Check price on Amazon

3

Best Sound UpgradeMaxhonor Fire Crackle Speaker

Electric fireplaces that look right but lack convincing fire sound

Check price on Amazon

4

Best Visual RefreshStyloVue Peel-and-Stick Fireplace Tile

Fireplace surrounds that need a fast surface update

Check price on Amazon

5

Best for Wood FiresNorthern Lights Fire Color Cones

Wood-burning fireplaces and outdoor fires needing colored flames

Check price on Amazon

#1Best Overall Insert

R.W.FLAME 30-Inch Recessed Fireplace

Best for Existing fireplaces needing recessed or wall-mounted electric heat

The 750W and 1500W settings give you supplemental heat for spaces up to 400 square feet, while the 3.86-inch depth suits recessed installation in 2 x 4 and 2 x 6 studs. Remote and touch controls, 12 flame and LED bed color modes, and five brightness levels make this the most flexible main pick.

Heat settings 750W and 1500WCoverage Up to 400 square feetDepth 3.86 inchesControls Touch screen and remote controlSafety ETL Certificate Approved; auto-heat kill safety

Why it made the cut

Recessed or wall-mounted installation

12 flame and LED bed color modes

Auto-heat kill safety feature

Good to know

Designed for supplemental zone heating

Requires installation planning for a recessed mount

Skip it if Skip it if you want a freestanding stove-style fireplace instead of a wall installation.

Check price on Amazon

#2Best Freestanding Style

R.W.FLAME 17-Inch Electric Stove

Best for Rooms that need a portable, vintage-style electric fireplace

The freestanding stove format brings an arched door, fence design, and three-sided clear glass to rooms where a recessed insert won’t work. Independent flame operation lets you run the four flame colors and four wood-log colors without heat, while 500W and 1500W infrared settings handle cooler days.

Heat settings 500W and 1500WFlame controls 4 flame colors and 5 flame speed levelsLog colors 4 wood log colorsConstruction Steel structureSafety Over-heating protection

Why it made the cut

Freestanding steel construction

Independent flame effect without heat

Four wood-log colors and four flame colors

Good to know

Smaller 17-inch format

Not a recessed fireplace insert

Skip it if Skip it if your existing fireplace opening requires a built-in or wall-mounted unit.

Check price on Amazon

#3Best Sound Upgrade

Maxhonor Fire Crackle Speaker

Best for Electric fireplaces that look right but lack convincing fire sound

The rechargeable speaker adds adjustable crackling sounds without taking another cord to the fireplace area. Several sound modes, volume levels, a compact portable body, and an auto shutoff timer let you tune the effect without turning the room into a small theater production.

Power Rechargeable batteryCharging USB chargingControls Multiple sound options and adjustable volumeTimer Auto shutoff timerPlacement Mantel, shelf, or near the firebox

Why it made the cut

Rechargeable battery with USB charging

Several crackling sound modes

Auto shutoff timer

Good to know

Adds sound only, not heat

Needs charging between uses

Skip it if Skip it if you want an electric insert rather than an ambiance accessory.

Check price on Amazon

#4Best Visual Refresh

StyloVue Peel-and-Stick Fireplace Tile

Best for Fireplace surrounds that need a fast surface update

The PVC backsplash uses peel-and-stick installation for fireplace surrounds and other surfaces, so you can refresh the look without professional tools. Its waterproof, heat-resistant construction and white marble finish suit a cosmetic upgrade, but it won’t add heat or flame effects.

Material PVC polymerFinish White marble with metal silver lookIncluded 20 sheets and a cleaning clothInstallation Peel and stickUse Fireplaces, kitchen backsplashes, bathrooms, and RVs

Why it made the cut

Peel-and-stick installation

Waterproof and heat-resistant PVC

Includes 20 sheets and a cleaning cloth

Good to know

Does not provide heat

Requires careful measurements before applying

Skip it if Skip it if your main goal is warmth or a more realistic electric flame.

Check price on Amazon

#5Best for Wood Fires

Northern Lights Fire Color Cones

Best for Wood-burning fireplaces and outdoor fires needing colored flames

These treated pine cones change active wood flames to blue, green, and purple tones after you add two or three cones. They belong with a wood-burning fireplace, campfire, fire pit, or chiminea—not an electric insert—so they rank last for this buying guide.

Use Wood-burning units, fire pits, campfires, and chimineasApplication Toss two or three cones into an active fireMaterial Pine cones treated with color-enhancing saltsFlame colors Blues, greens, and purples

Why it made the cut

Creates blue, green, and purple flames

No messy powder application

Burns down with the wood

Good to know

Works with active wood fires only

Does not add heat to an electric fireplace

Skip it if Skip it for an electric fireplace; it needs an active wood fire.

Check price on Amazon

Faq about best electric insert for existing fireplace installation:

An electric fireplace insert is a device designed to fit into an existing fireplace, providing heat and ambiance without the need for venting or major renovations.

Select an electric insert based on size, heating capacity, style, and features like remote control, adjustable flame settings, and energy efficiency.

Yes, most electric inserts are designed for easy installation and can often be done without professional help, requiring only an electrical outlet.

Benefits include ease of installation, energy efficiency, low maintenance, and the ability to enjoy a flame effect without real fire hazards.

Yes, electric fireplace inserts are generally safe, as they do not produce real flames and often include safety features like automatic shut-off.

Prices for electric fireplace inserts vary widely, typically ranging from $200 to $1,500, depending on brand, features, and size.

Conclusion

Both the GLACER Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote and the PuraFlame 33″ Electric Fireplace Insert epitomize excellence in modern heating solutions. The GLACER model stands out with its user-friendly remote control and realistic flame effects, ensuring a cozy ambiance with minimal effort.

Meanwhile, the PuraFlame insert captivates with its elegant design and impressive heating capabilities, making it a sophisticated addition to any living space. Together, these products exemplify the fusion of functionality and aesthetic appeal, redefining comfort in contemporary homes.