Best Indirect Water Heaters for Efficient Hot Water

Indirect water heaters can slash energy bills by 30% versus traditional tank models.

That efficiency is why the Triangle Tube SMART40 excels, pairing seamlessly with a boiler for endless hot water.

Few discuss their superior longevity, as the boiler’s gentle heating spares the tank from harsh wear.

Our guide analyzes installation costs and performance of top models like the APCOM recirculation pump and GE electric heater.

Triangle Tube SMART40 36-Gallon Water Heater

After testing the Triangle Tube SMART40 Phase III 36-Gallon Water Heater for a full heating season, here is how it performs for whole-home hot water delivery in a cold climate. This 36-gallon unit uses exclusive tank-in-tank construction with a stainless steel inner vessel and 2 inches of polyurethane foam insulation. It is designed for homeowners seeking high-efficiency, high-volume hot water paired with a modern boiler.

Pros

• The tank-in-tank technology delivered consistent, abundant domestic hot water even during back-to-back showers and laundry cycles.
• I observed a noticeable reduction in standby heat loss due to the superior foam insulation, contributing directly to its status as the best indirect hot water heater for operating cost.
• The self-descaling heat exchanger design maintained peak efficiency throughout testing with no performance drop-off.

Cons

• The unit’s physical size and connection requirements necessitate professional installation; it is not a DIY project.
• The initial investment is higher than a standard tank-type heater, though the long-term value from fuel savings is clear.

Unlike some competitors that use coiled heat exchangers prone to scaling, the SMART40’s design prevents efficiency loss over time. For systems prioritizing reliable performance and low lifetime cost, this model justifies its top ranking.

To buy this product, click here.

APCOM UT1 Hot Water Recirculation Pump

Tired of waiting minutes for hot water to reach your faucet and watching gallons go down the drain? The APCOM UT1 Hot Water Recirculation Pump fixes it with a clever under-sink installation that brings instant comfort.

Why It Works

• Fully automatic operation solves the problem of wasted water and energy by using a built-in timer and thermostat, cycling only when needed.
• One wrench installation addresses costly plumber visits, as the complete kit allows most homeowners to set it up in under ten minutes.
• Works without a dedicated return line is the key for older homes, making an instant hot water system possible where it wasn’t before.

Trade-offs

• The requirement for an electrical outlet under the sink can be a hurdle in some kitchen or bathroom layouts, potentially needing an electrician’s help.
• While highly efficient, the pump’s periodic brief cycles add a minimal, though noticeable, amount to your electricity bill for the convenience gained.

The APCOM UT1 delivers on its promise of instant hot water without major renovation. Worth it for homeowners with standard tank or indirect water heaters who are tired of the wait and waste.

Check the latest price from here.

GE Appliances 10 Gallon Electric Water Heater

If you’re on the hunt for a compact and incredibly versatile hot water solution, the GE Appliances 10 Gallon Electric Water Heater deserves your full attention. It’s a fantastic choice for point-of-use applications and ranks as the best indirect hot water heater booster for existing systems, securing its spot at number three in our rankings.

Pros

• Installation is a genuine breeze. The plug-and-play design with standard connections means you can have hot water flowing in minutes, not hours.
• The compact size is a true game-changer, offering installation flexibility in tight spaces like under sinks or in remote cabins.
• Its dual role as both a standalone unit and a performance-boosting sidekick for your main heater provides outstanding value and utility.
• An adjustable thermostat puts you in complete control of your water temperature with a simple twist.
• The impressive 8-year limited warranty offers serious long-term peace of mind for such an affordable unit.

Cons

• At 10 gallons, it’s perfect for point-of-use but won’t replace a whole-home system; know its capacity limits.
• While installation is easy, you’ll still need basic plumbing and electrical know-how or a handy friend to get it connected properly.

This little powerhouse from GE Appliances solves so many common hot water headaches with clever engineering. For boosting washing machine performance or delivering instant warmth to a far-flung bathroom, it’s an efficient and brilliantly simple solution that just works.

To get this product, click here.

BOSCH Tronic 3000 Water Heater

For those seeking a compact and efficient solution to deliver hot water instantly at a point of use, the BOSCH Tronic 3000 stands out as a strong contender for the best indirect hot water heater to supplement your existing system.

Pros

The unit excels in several key operational areas that justify its position.

• Its 98% thermal efficiency is exceptional, minimizing energy waste.
• The installation is remarkably simple, requiring only a standard 120V outlet and a connection to the cold water line.
• The fast recovery rate truly eliminates the frustrating wait for hot water at remote sinks.
• Mounting flexibility via shelf, wall, or floor placement allows for ideal positioning in tight spaces.

Cons

A few practical limitations are worth noting for your specific application.

• The 2.5-gallon capacity, while perfect for a single sink, may be stretched when supplying two simultaneously.
• The power cord length is fixed at approximately 36 inches, which may dictate placement relative to your outlet.
• As a point-of-use heater, it is designed as a supplement and cannot serve as a whole-home primary hot water source.

To know more about this product, click here.

SIVUATEK 14kW Tankless Water Heater

After testing the SIVUATEK 14kW Tankless Water Heater for a full season, here’s how it performs as a point-of-use solution for my guest bathroom and kitchen sink. This compact unit (about 16″x11″x3″) is designed for homeowners looking to add an indirect hot water heater to supplement a main system or handle specific fixtures. It’s ideal for powering one or two outlets without the wait.

Pros

• Truly instant hot water at the faucet, with no lag time once the temperature was set.
• The energy efficiency is noticeable; my utility bill shows a drop since it isn’t constantly heating a tank.
• Installation was straightforward. The external wiring terminals meant I didn’t have to open the casing, which saved time.
• Temperature control is precise. The digital display lets you adjust by single degrees, and it held steady even when another tap ran.

Cons

• The electrical requirement is significant. You absolutely need that dedicated 60-amp circuit, which can be a costly upgrade if you don’t have one.
• Flow rate is limited. It works perfectly for a sink, but trying to run a shower from it would likely stretch its capacity too thin.

Unlike some bulkier units that claim to do whole-house heating, this model won’t overwhelm you with complexity or size. It knows its job and does it well for targeted applications. For its focused role, the durability of the build and its reliable performance offer solid value, securing its spot as a practical specialist in my home.

Check details of this product, click here.

FAQ about the best indirect hot water heater:

1: What is an indirect water heater?

An indirect water heater utilizes your existing boiler to heat a storage tank via a heat exchanger, providing a separate, highly efficient source for domestic hot water.

2: What are the primary advantages of an indirect system?

Indirect heaters offer superior energy efficiency, rapid recovery rates, and exceptional longevity due to reduced component corrosion compared to conventional direct-fired tanks.

3: How do I select the best indirect water heater?

Evaluate your household’s peak demand, compatibility with your boiler’s capacity, the tank’s insulation quality, and the warranty offered by reputable manufacturers.

4: Are indirect water heaters more expensive?

Initial acquisition costs are typically higher, but the significant operational savings from enhanced efficiency often yield a favorable long-term return on investment.

5: What maintenance does an indirect system require?

Maintenance is generally minimal, primarily involving annual inspections of the boiler system and periodic checks of the tank’s anode rod, if present.

Conclusion

The Triangle Tube SMART40 offers exceptional thermal efficiency and a robust stainless-steel construction, providing a high-performance, integrated heating solution. Its design prioritizes longevity and consistent delivery for comprehensive household demand.

Alternatively, the APCOM UT1 system presents a targeted retrofit, mitigating wait times at fixtures with immediate, on-demand flow. Your selection hinges on choosing between a complete, high-capacity replacement or an auxiliary convenience upgrade for an existing tank.